everything spud explains

spud explains

were watermelons always red?

the short answer

no. watermelon's closest wild cousin, the kordofan melon from sudan, has whitish flesh. over thousands of years, farmers kept seeds from the sweetest, reddest melons, and the red is lycopene, the same pigment that makes tomatoes red. even a painting from the 1600s shows a melon that's pale and barely red.

the 30 second version. sound on.

watch it oninstagramtiktokyoutube

watermelons used to be white

watermelons weren't always red. gary saw an old one and said it was broken. it's not broken. it's from a painting.

spud with watermelon seeds stuck to his cheek and gary with a juicy face beside a big bitten slice of red watermelon on a picnic blanket
thousands of years of breeding. gary finished it in four minutes.

the painting

an italian painter named giovanni stanchi painted this watermelon sometime between 1645 and 1672, so it's over 350 years old. cut one open today and it's red all the way through. his is pale, swirly and barely red, packed with seeds.

an old framed painting of a sliced watermelon with pale pink swirly flesh, labeled 1600s, pale, swirly, barely red
the 1600s. pale. swirly. barely red.

plant scientists like showing it to their students because it's a snapshot of a melon that hadn't finished being bred yet. it's one painting of one melon, so it's a clue, not proof. but it fits everything else we know.

the wild cousin

the closest living wild cousin of the watermelon is the kordofan melon, from sudan in northeast africa. scientists read its whole genome in 2021 and found it's the nearest relative of the melons we eat. and inside, it's whitish. not red at all.

a pale pink watermelon slice labeled 1600s next to a white slice labeled wild cousin, from sudan, africa, white inside
the cousin. white inside. not broken either.

the same study found the red only became fixed in the watermelons people grew. the wild ones didn't have it.

how it turned red

farmers did it, slowly. every harvest, they kept the seeds from the sweetest, reddest melons and planted those. do that for thousands of years and the melons get redder, sweeter and juicier.

five watermelon slices in a row going from white to deep red, over a line labeled thousands of years
a little redder every time.

people in ancient egypt were already eating watermelon more than 4,000 years ago. it's an old project.

what makes it red?

the red is lycopene. it's the same red that's in tomatoes. a ripe watermelon actually has about 40 percent more of it than a raw tomato.

a bright red watermelon slice labeled lycopene, same red
lycopene. tomato red.

so old watermelons weren't worse. they were vintage.

the old watermelon painting in its gold frame with a small sign underneath that says vintage
vintage.

gary says i'm vintage too. i'm choosing to take that well.

if you like little facts, i keep a field of them in spudnote. it's a notes app where every note grows into a sprout. i live there.

people also ask spud

what color were wild watermelons?

pale. the kordofan melon from sudan, the watermelon's closest living wild relative, has whitish, non-bitter flesh. the deep red was bred in by farmers over thousands of years.

what makes watermelon red?

lycopene, the same red pigment that's in tomatoes. ripe red watermelon has about 40 percent more lycopene than raw tomatoes.

what is the old watermelon painting?

a still life by giovanni stanchi, painted in rome between 1645 and 1672. its watermelon has pale, pinkish flesh full of seeds, and plant breeding teachers use it to show how much watermelons have changed.

where spud read this

  1. A seedy slice of history: Watermelons actually came from northeast Africa, Washington University in St. Louis, on Renner et al., PNAS, 2021 (the kordofan melon from sudan, with non-bitter whitish pulp, is the closest relative of domesticated watermelons; egyptian tomb paintings suggest watermelon was eaten in the nile valley more than 4,000 years ago)
  2. A chromosome-level genome of a Kordofan melon illuminates the origin of domesticated watermelons, Renner et al., PNAS, 2021 (the kordofan melon is the nearest living relative and a possible ancestor; red flesh became fixed only in domesticated watermelon)
  3. The Evolution of the Watermelon, Captured in Still Lifes, Hyperallergic, 2015 (giovanni stanchi's watermelons, peaches, pears and other fruit in a landscape (1645 to 1672) shows pale, pinkish flesh full of seeds; a university of wisconsin horticulture professor uses it to teach how breeding changed the fruit)
  4. Watermelon Packs a Powerful Lycopene Punch, USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2002 (lycopene is the red pigment in both watermelon and tomatoes; watermelon has about 40 percent more lycopene than raw tomatoes on average)

sources checked nov 12, 2026.

spudnote

notes so simple a potato could use them

Download on the App Store