everything spud explains

spud explains

why do onions make you cry?

the short answer

an onion keeps a sulfur chemical and an enzyme apart in its cells. cutting it breaks the cells open, they mix, and a second enzyme turns the result into a gas that floats up and stings your eyes, so your eyes make tears to wash it out. it's a defense against things that want to eat it.

the 57 second version. sound on.

watch it oninstagramtiktokyoutube

it's on purpose

onions make you cry on purpose. the onion says it's not a defense, it's a boundary. it's a defense.

spud crying with a tissue box on his head next to a cut onion, gary calm beside it in tiny sunglasses
spud brought tissues. gary brought sunglasses.

an onion is made of tiny cells. a sulfur chemical sits in one part of each cell, and an enzyme waits in another, sealed away in a little pocket. they're kept apart, like gary and the onion at a party.

a zoomed-in circle of onion cells with yellow dots labeled sulfur chemical and blue dots labeled enzyme, kept apart
sulfur chemical here. enzyme over there. no touching.

then you cut it

the knife breaks the cells open and the two mix. the enzyme turns the sulfur chemical into something new, and then a second enzyme turns that into a gas. it floats up off the cutting board and lands in your eyes.

your eyes sting, so they make tears to wash it out. that's the crying. you're not sad. your eyes are cleaning.

a wide open eye with red sting lines and tears falling, faint gas below
sting. tears. wash it out.

why would it do that?

so animals don't eat it. an onion can't run away, so it makes biting it unpleasant. bugs and other hungry things get the same sting you do, just with less drama.

an onion with a bite out of it inside a blue shield, a red cross over the bite, labeled defense
one bite and you regret it.

why doesn't garlic make you cry?

garlic has the first enzyme, but not the second one, the one that makes the tear gas. so its chemistry goes a different way and makes allicin, the garlicky smell, instead. all smell, no tears.

a sliced onion giving off gas and making an eye tear, next to a garlic bulb labeled missing: 1 enzyme
garlic: missing one enzyme.

can you stop it?

farmers bred onions that barely make you cry. one kind took about 30 years of crossing onions and keeping the mildest ones. no lab tricks. just a lot of onions.

two small onions plus an arrow make one big onion labeled no tears, next to a calendar labeled decades
no tears. took decades.

the easier trick: chill the onion before you cut it. cold slows the reaction down, so less gas reaches your eyes. don't leave it in there for days though. it goes soggy.

a sliced onion in an open fridge with snowflakes and a thermometer labeled cold
the fridge. the onion has feelings about this.

it's okay to cry, buddy. it's the onion's fault.

if you like little facts, i keep a field of them in spudnote. it's a notes app where every note grows into a sprout. i live there.

people also ask spud

what is the gas that comes out of onions?

it's called the lachrymatory factor, propanethial s-oxide. it's made by an enzyme called lachrymatory factor synthase the moment the onion's cells are broken.

why doesn't garlic make you cry?

garlic has alliinase, the first enzyme, but not the one that makes the tear gas. its chemistry makes allicin, the smell of garlic, instead.

does chilling an onion stop the tears?

it helps. cold slows the reaction, so less gas reaches your eyes. a short chill is enough; weeks in the fridge make onions soggy.

where spud read this

  1. Why onions make us cry (and why some don't), The Conversation (cutting rips the cells open; alliinase, then lachrymatory factor synthase, make the volatile irritant that reaches the eyes; it's there to stop pests eating the plant; garlic's chemistry makes allicin instead; chilling slows the reaction, long refrigeration makes onions soggy)
  2. Plant biochemistry: an onion enzyme that makes the eyes water, Imai et al., Nature, 2002 (Scientific American) (the tear gas comes from a second enzyme, lachrymatory factor synthase, not from alliinase alone; garlic has alliinase and doesn't make you cry)
  3. Understanding the defense mechanism of Allium plants through the onion isoallicin-omics study, Cho et al., Frontiers in Plant Science, 2024 (alliinase is kept in the cell's vacuole and released when the cell is damaged; a defense against herbivores and insects)
  4. Stop Crying! Tear-Free Onions Are Here, NPR, The Salt, 2018 (WGBH) (the tear-free Sunion took about 30 years of old-fashioned cross-breeding, keeping the least pungent bulbs)

sources checked nov 11, 2026.

spudnote

notes so simple a potato could use them

Download on the App Store