why does the corpse flower smell so bad?
the corpse flower smells like rotting meat on purpose.
spud explains
the short answer
every granny smith comes from one tree: a chance seedling maria ann smith found on her farm in eastwood, sydney, around 1868. apple seeds don't grow true to their parents, so every granny smith tree since has been grown from cuttings of hers, grafted onto other trees' roots.
i planted a seed from a granny smith. gary asked what i'd get. honestly? no idea.


an apple tree can't make apples with its own pollen. the pollen has to come from a different apple tree. so every apple seed is a mix of two trees. like a kid.

and the kid almost never looks like the parents. apple seedlings are all different from each other and from their parents, and they're usually worse than the tree they came from. plant a granny smith seed and you'll most likely get a disappointing apple.

you cheat. you cut a twig off the tree you want and join it onto another tree's roots. they grow together, and the twig keeps growing the same apples as the tree it came from. it's called grafting.

a grafted tree has one parent, so it's a copy. that's how most apple trees are grown.
in 1868, in eastwood, sydney, maria ann smith found a little apple tree that had come up by itself near a creek on her farm. a lucky one. she grew more of it. she died in 1870, and local growers kept it going.

every granny smith tree since then has been grown from cuttings that go back to her tree. so every granny smith you've ever eaten came off one tree. sort of.

gary is planting his own seed anyway. i told him a tree grown on its own roots is much slower to fruit. he said he's a snail.

if you like little facts, i keep a field of them in spudnote. it's a notes app where every note grows into a sprout. i live there.
you can grow an apple tree from a granny smith seed, but it won't be a granny smith. each apple seed is a cross between two trees, and seedlings are usually worse than their parents. granny smith trees are made by grafting cuttings instead.
joining a twig cut from the tree you want onto the roots of another tree, called the rootstock. they grow together, and the twig keeps making the same fruit as the tree it came from.
maria ann smith, born in sussex, england, in 1799. she found the first granny smith tree as a chance seedling on her farm in eastwood, sydney, around 1868, and died in 1870.
nobody knows for sure. it's thought to be a cross between the european wild apple and a domestic apple.
sources checked nov 15, 2026.